Billboard’s Greatest Pop Stars vs Viberate’s Top Artists

Kristian Gorenc Z

Dec 5, 2024

Recently, Billboard unveiled its Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century list, highlighting the artists who have shaped pop music over the last 25 years. While this list recognizes cultural impact, legacy, and broad influence, at Viberate, we focus on a more data-driven approach to tracking artist performance, using real-time streaming metrics and social media engagement. In this article, we’ll compare Billboard’s top artists to Viberate’s rankings, analyzing why certain stars appear where they do on each list.

📌 Viberate Analytics: Professional music analytics suite at an unbeatable price: $19.90/mo. Charts, talent discovery tools, plus Spotify, TikTok, and other channel-specific analytics of every artist out there.

1. Billboard’s Top 5 vs Viberate’s Top 5: Who Ranks Where and Why?

Billboard’s Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century list features some of the biggest names in pop, with Beyoncé, Taylor Swift, Rihanna, Drake, and Lady Gaga leading the pack. In comparison, Viberate’s ranking system places Billie Eilish at the top, followed by Taylor Swift, Bruno Mars, Sabrina Carpenter, and Ariana Grande.

Consistency Across Lists: Taylor Swift

One of the few constants across both rankings is Taylor Swift, who maintains a solid second-place ranking in both lists. As an artist with both immense cultural influence and consistent streaming success, her position is backed by millions of Spotify followers and monthly listeners, which also fuels her social media engagement.

Divergence: Billie Eilish and Bruno Mars

Where the lists start to diverge significantly is in the placement of Billie Eilish and Bruno Mars. Billboard places Beyoncé at #1, reflecting her lasting cultural influence and role as a pop icon. However, Viberate places Billie Eilish at the top, driven by her dominance on platforms like Spotify, YouTube, and TikTok. With over 102 million followers on Spotify and billions of streams, Billie’s metrics show that she has a level of engagement and popularity that rivals or even surpasses many of the traditional pop icons in Billboard’s ranking.

Bruno Mars, who is third on Viberate’s list, ranks significantly lower on Billboard’s (at #20). Viberate’s rankings reflect his impressive streaming numbers, with high monthly listeners and consistent performance on Spotify and YouTube. Bruno Mars' current popularity in the digital space has pushed him higher in Viberate’s rankings compared to Billboard’s legacy-focused approach.

New Faces in Viberate’s Top 5

Sabrina Carpenter, who ranks fourth on Viberate, and Ariana Grande, in fifth, also stand out in Viberate’s rankings. While Billboard places Ariana Grande in the top 10, Sabrina Carpenter doesn’t even make Billboard’s top 25. Viberate’s ranking system highlights Sabrina’s rapidly growing streaming numbers, particularly among younger audiences, as her music gains traction across platforms like Spotify, YouTube, and TikTok. This positions her higher in Viberate’s rankings, reflecting the power of social media-driven music consumption.

2. The Impact of Genre: Pop, Hip Hop, and Latin Music

Both Billboard and Viberate’s rankings are dominated by pop artists, but Viberate’s list includes a stronger presence of Latin and Hip Hop artists.

Latin Influence: Karol G and Shakira

Viberate highlights the increasing global reach of Latin artists, with Karol G ranking 10th and Shakira in 12th. Billboard’s list also features Shakira (#17), but Karol G doesn’t make the top 25. This is likely due to Viberate’s focus on real-time streaming data, where Karol G’s numbers on platforms like Spotify, YouTube, and Instagram have been soaring, reflecting the growing popularity of Latin music, especially in streaming metrics.

Shakira, meanwhile, has seen a significant surge in her YouTube views and continues to enjoy massive popularity in both Latin and global markets. Her streaming numbers place her higher in Viberate’s rankings compared to Billboard’s more legacy-based approach.

Hip Hop’s Representation: Eminem and Drake

Both Billboard and Viberate acknowledge the influence of Hip Hop, with Eminem and Drake ranking highly. On Billboard, Eminem is ranked #12, while Drake is #4. Viberate’s rankings place Drake at #20, while Eminem is in 7th place. Viberate’s rankings are more influenced by current streaming success, where Drake, despite his legendary status, has seen fluctuations in his streaming performance in recent months, while Eminem’s consistent fanbase and engagement across platforms have kept him higher on Viberate’s charts.

3. Streaming Power: Spotify and YouTube Dominance

Viberate’s ranking system is built on streaming data, and this is where the differences between the lists become more apparent. Billboard’s rankings take into account long-term influence and cultural legacy, but Viberate’s focus on current streaming metrics provides a snapshot of today’s pop music landscape.

Billie Eilish’s Streaming Success

Billie Eilish is a prime example of how streaming power can influence rankings. She tops Viberate’s list due to her massive presence on Spotify, with over 102 million followers, and her YouTube views, which total over 16 billion. Billie’s high streaming numbers place her at the forefront of Viberate’s rankings, showing that she is a dominant force in the current streaming era.

On the other hand, Billboard’s list places Beyoncé at the top, a testament to her cultural influence across multiple decades. While Beyoncé is still a force in streaming, her numbers don’t match the sheer volume of Billie’s recent success. This discrepancy highlights how Viberate’s data-driven approach can shine a light on newer artists who may not have the long-term cultural weight but are dominating the digital music scene.

Taylor Swift’s Consistency

Taylor Swift’s consistent ranking in both Billboard and Viberate reflects her immense staying power. As one of the most-streamed artists on Spotify and with a massive presence on social media, she continues to thrive in both the traditional and digital music spaces. Her data points in Viberate, including millions of monthly listeners and billions of streams, ensure that she remains a key player in today’s music landscape.

4. Social Media Influence: Instagram and TikTok

Social media presence is becoming an increasingly important factor in determining pop stardom. Viberate’s data shows how Instagram and TikTok are shaping the popularity of artists today.

Instagram and TikTok Stars

Billie Eilish and Ariana Grande are among the artists who stand out in both streaming and social media. Billie Eilish has over 68 million Instagram followers, and Ariana Grande has over 376 million, making them two of the most-followed artists globally. Both of these artists rank high in Viberate’s list, with Billie at #1 and Ariana at #5, due to their immense engagement across these platforms.

Viberate’s focus on social media metrics gives a more immediate sense of an artist’s influence, with Instagram and TikTok being major factors in defining pop stardom today. In comparison, Billboard’s rankings focus more on cultural milestones and long-term impact, which may explain why artists like Lady Gaga and Selena Gomez, who have significant social media followings, are not as high on their list.

5. Global Reach: BTS, Karol G, and Latin Music

Viberate’s rankings place a stronger emphasis on global reach, with artists like BTS and Karol G ranking higher than on Billboard’s list. BTS, for example, ranks 15th on Viberate, but only 19th on Billboard’s. This difference is attributed to BTS’s global fanbase and their unmatched streaming numbers, particularly on platforms like YouTube and Spotify, where they dominate.

Latin artists like Karol G, Shakira, and Bad Bunny also perform better in Viberate’s list due to the growing international influence of Latin music. Karol G, who ranks 10th on Viberate, is not even in the top 25 of Billboard’s list, despite having significant global success on streaming platforms.

6. Longevity vs Current Relevance

Billboard’s list leans heavily on an artist’s cultural longevity and impact, which is why legacy artists like Britney Spears, Kanye West, and Usher feature prominently. These artists have shaped the pop landscape for decades and continue to influence music and culture today.

Viberate’s rankings, however, are more focused on current relevance, with newer artists like Billie Eilish, Sabrina Carpenter, and Karol G rising to the top. While these artists may not have the same historical legacy as others, their influence in the digital age—driven by streaming numbers, social media engagement, and fanbase loyalty—has propelled them to the forefront of Viberate’s rankings.

Conclusion: Legacy vs Streaming Power

The difference between Billboard’s Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century and Viberate’s artist rankings lies in the metrics used to define pop greatness. Billboard’s list celebrates artists with enduring cultural influence, while Viberate’s rankings reflect the current state of the music industry, driven by streaming power, social media engagement, and real-time data.

Both perspectives offer valuable insights into pop stardom today. Billboard captures the timeless legacy of artists who have shaped the musical and cultural landscape, while Viberate offers a snapshot of today’s music industry, highlighting the artists who are dominating the digital space in real-time. By comparing these two rankings, we gain a deeper understanding of how pop stardom is evolving in the 21st century, where streaming and social media are increasingly defining the artists who shape our musical world.